Warning: Array to string conversion in /home/thescoop.pk/public_html/wp-includes/shortcodes.php on line 433

ANALYSIS: The Battle Within – Pakistan’s Judiciary Confronts Internal Challenges


Share post:

As the Supreme Court of Pakistan continues to dissect layers of alleged interference in judicial matters, a profound statement by Justice Athar Minallah resonates with the gravity of the situation — “the truth was hidden for 76 years.” This remark came during the ongoing suo motu case, spotlighting a decades-long issue now being openly scrutinised at the highest levels of the judiciary.

The case pivots on a letter from six Islamabad High Court (IHC) judges who bravely broke silence about attempts to manipulate judicial outcomes. Allegations of abduction, torture of relatives, and covert surveillance within judges’ homes form the crux of this extraordinary judicial probe.

Historical Context and Judicial Pushback

This case is not merely about isolated incidents but reflects a systemic issue that has subtly influenced judicial processes in Pakistan. The letter, which triggered the current proceedings, was an unprecedented move by the judiciary to call out undue pressures from the country’s security apparatus, specifically implicating operatives from the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI).

Chief Justice Qazi Faez Isa, leading the six-member bench, underscores the necessity of transparency and justice, not just for the judiciary but for the Pakistani populace whom this saga ultimately affects. The proceedings, which are being live-streamed to ensure public accessibility and transparency, signal a new era of judicial openness and accountability.

Immediate Reactions and Judicial Strategies

The startling revelations prompted immediate responses, including a full court meeting of the Supreme Court justices convened by CJP Isa and discussions with Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif leading to the formation of an inquiry commission. However, the initial head of the commission, ex-CJP Tassaduq Hussain Jillani, recused himself, advocating for institutional resolutions rather than external inquiries, hinting at deep-rooted issues within the system.

As the Supreme Court delves into the case, the role of the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) has been highlighted, with suggestions to amend the judicial code of conduct to prevent future executive intrusions into judicial affairs. This move, while reinforcing judicial independence, also acknowledges potential systemic vulnerabilities that could undermine the judiciary’s authority.

Broader Implications for Judicial Independence

The IHC’s proactive measures, including the reactivation of empowered inspection teams, suggest a judicial branch ready to safeguard its autonomy vigorously. The discussions in the Supreme Court, where Justice Minallah pointed out the broader implications of such interference as a potential subversion of the Constitution, are pivotal. They not only address current issues but also set a precedent for handling future challenges to judicial independence.

The ongoing debates and the judiciary’s forceful response underscore a critical juncture for Pakistan’s legal system. The establishment of mechanisms to protect judges and ensure judicial independence against external pressures is seen not just as necessary but imperative for the sustenance of the rule of law.

As the hearings progress, with active participation from various legal bodies and the attorney general’s office, the Pakistani judiciary seems poised for significant reforms. The outcomes of this case could potentially redefine the power dynamics between the state’s organs, particularly emphasising the judiciary’s independence as sacrosanct.

This judicial saga, while distressing, provides a beacon of hope for those advocating for an unbiased and robust judiciary in Pakistan. The ultimate resolution of this case will not only determine the future of judicial independence but could also restore or further erode public trust in the system. The nation watches as its judiciary confronts these longstanding shadows, aiming to bring forth a transparent, accountable, and independent judicial system.


Hassan Naqvi
Hassan Naqvi
Hassan Naqvi is an award-winning digital, print, and broadcast investigative journalist who is the co-founder of The Scoop. He also hosts his web shows 'The Scoop' and 'The Hassan Naqvi Show'.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Related articles

Faisal Vawda Discusses Malik Riaz’s Endorsement Of Imran Khan And PTI’s 1971 Narrative

In a recent appearance on the Aik News show, hosted by Batool Rajput and Fahd Husain, Senator Faisal...

My Only Regret Is Trusting General Bajwa, Says Imran Khan

In an exclusive interview conducted from his prison cell, former Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan, speaking with interviewer...

Establishment Strive To Keep Imran Khan Behind Bars: PTI Spokesperson Raoof Hasan

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) Information Secretary, Raoof Hasan, has alleged that state institutions are making efforts to ensure...

Nawaz Sharif Signals Expansion Of Punjab, Federal Cabinets

LAHORE: Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) President Nawaz Sharif has indicated an upcoming expansion of both the Punjab and...